By Parimal Patil
Philosophical arguments for and opposed to the lifestyles of God were an important to Euro-American and South Asian philosophers for over a millennium. serious to the historical past of philosophy in India, have been the centuries-long arguments among Buddhist and Hindu philosophers in regards to the lifestyles of a God-like being referred to as Isvara and the spiritual epistemology used to help them. through targeting the paintings of Ratnakirti, one of many final nice Buddhist philosophers of India, and his arguments opposed to his Hindu rivals, Parimal G. Patil illuminates South Asian highbrow practices and the character of philosophy in the course of the ultimate section of Buddhism in India.
Based on the recognized college of Vikramasila, Ratnakirti introduced the whole variety of Buddhist philosophical assets to undergo on his critique of his Hindu competitors' cosmological/design argument. At stake in his critique used to be not anything below the character of inferential reasoning, the metaphysics of epistemology, and the relevance of philosophy to the perform of faith. In constructing a formal comparative method of the philosophy of faith, Patil transcends the disciplinary limitations of non secular experiences, philosophy, and South Asian reviews and applies the extraordinary paintings of philosophers like Ratnakirti to modern concerns in philosophy and faith.
Read or Download Against a Hindu God: Buddhist Philosophy of Religion In India PDF
Similar hinduism books
Hanuman, the dedicated monkey helper of Rama and Sita, has lengthy been well-known as a favored personality in India's historic Ramayana epic. yet extra lately he has additionally develop into some of the most loved and worshiped gods within the Hindu pantheon - enshrined in majestic new temples, yet both found in poster artwork, ads, and mass media.
Vedanta is the main encompassing and open of the six orthodox platforms of Hinduism and is taken into account the quintessence of jap suggestion and mysticism. a big a part of glossy highbrow Hinduism, Vedanta is usually considered as a really common faith and had many adherents within the West. on the middle of Vedanta lie the texts of the Upanishads and the Bhagavad Gita.
The violent partitioning of British India alongside non secular strains and ongoing communalist aggression have pressured Indian voters to deal with the idea that an particular, fastened non secular identification is prime to selfhood. however, Muslim saint shrines referred to as dargahs allure a religiously assorted variety of pilgrims.
- Gandhi and Nehru
- Trika Saivism of Kashmir
- Colonizing the Realm of Words: The Transformation of Tamil Literature in Nineteenth-Century South India (SUNY Series in Hindu Studies)
- A Concise Encyclopedia of Hinduism (Concise Encyclopedia of World Faiths)
- Rethinking Religion in India: The Colonial Construction of Hinduism (Routledge South Asian Religion)
Extra resources for Against a Hindu God: Buddhist Philosophy of Religion In India
32. For a short but extremely useful summary discussion of Ratnakirti’s intellectual context see Granoff 1978:1– 2; also see Thakur 1975. 33 It is equally important to recognize that while Ratnakirti’s work may be of historical interest to many, it is certainly not the case that it was merely of historical interest to him or his interlocutors. 34 As a result, when they are studied in this location it is not sufﬁcient to treat them as such. The danger in doing so is that lively and important philosophical and theological arguments will be reduced to conversations about the meanings of technical terms and concepts, and that the diverse and varied history of these arguments will be reduced to exercises in intellectual archaeology, where one’s primary task is to uncover layers of argument and counterargument until their “origin” is discovered.
Without understanding this technical language, it is simply impossible to appreciate and understand even the general character of Sanskrit philosophy of religion, let alone the speciﬁc details of interreligious debates between Buddhist and Nyaya phi losophers. The purpose of this chapter is to provide an introduction to the philosophical language and style of Sanskrit epistemology, and to Buddhist and Nyaya theories of inferential reasoning more speciﬁcally. I seek to develop a conceptual vocabulary for understanding both the philosophical details of Ratnakirti’s debate with his Nyaya opponents and what is at stake in it.
5). The effort to interpret Ratnakirti’s arguments as a part of this intellectual and intertextual context recognizes the importance of trying to understand these arguments as Ratnakirti and the other Sanskrit philosophers of his time did. 29 26. For the idea of a historicist approach to the philosophy of religions see Bowlin 1999. For some excellent recent examples of historicist approaches to Sanskrit philosophy see Dunne 2004, Phillips and Tatacharya 2004, and Taber 2005. 27. ” 28. For some recent examples that set the standards for such work see Dunne 2004, Kapstein 2001, Katsura 2004, Kellner 1997a, Krasser 1999, Lasic 2000a, Taber 2005, and Tillemans 2000.